Should Ed_the_king be allowed back in?

From this point forward I will request the opinion from the members of GN, because I want us all to be a close knit alliance. Ed_the_king, a former GN member who left during the war and joined HBC has applied for readmission to GN. I will make the following notes regarding Ed_the_king
.
He did not stay with us during the war, showing no loyalty and respect for each and one of us and the tag we proudly wear. Although as a player and bureaucrat, he could help us in improving our infrastructure as an alliance. His abilities are more of that in administration and not fighting.
.
Please go to this link and post your opinion and vote on the matter to allow Ed_the_king back in. Do not post on mass mail as it will pile up and become difficult to read through.

I will not ask for much from everyone. You do not have to vote, but I would enjoy your thoughts and opinion as citizens of GN

In response to Maodou :This is Ed_the_king's application message : i want to rejoin GN i like HBC but i like it better here will u let me back in

In his application, did he provide a statement for why he left?

i remember ed_the_ and really liked him

LET HIM BACK

SO SAYETH ME